Pick TradeReview if
You want to start free without a card, journal several markets in one account, and review on a phone. Paid tiers start at $9.90/mo.
Trading journal
comparisons
TradeReview against the three journals traders shortlist most — TradeZella, Edgewonk and TradesViz. Figures come from each vendor’s own pricing page and were last checked on 15 September 2026. Anything marked “approx.” is recorded in our data as still needing confirmation at the source.
The short answer
Pick TradeZella if
You trade prop-firm evaluations and want the ecosystem with the largest community and the most tutorial content behind it.
Pick Edgewonk if
Psychology is the problem you are solving. Its behavioural tooling is deeper than ours and that is the honest answer.
Pick TradesViz if
You want the deepest statistics and the most configurable dashboards — 600+ stats — and you do not mind a steeper learning curve.
Side by side
Checked 15 Sep 2026 · approx. figures need confirming at source
| Feature | TradeReview | TradeZella | Edgewonk | TradesViz |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Yes, no card | No free tier | No — 14-day money-back | Yes — Free Basic, forever |
| Entry paid price | $9.90/mo · $99/yr | Essential ~$35/moapprox. | ~$197/yrapprox. | Pro ~$19.99/moapprox. |
| Top tier | Pro $19.90/mo · $199/yr | Ultra ~$99/moapprox. | Single annual plan, full access | Platinum ~$29.99/moapprox. |
| Native mobile apps | iOS and Android | Web only — mobile is a common criticism | Browser only | iOS and Android |
| Broker connection | Manual free · file import Basic · Auto Sync Pro | Many brokers advertised; sync reliability is a recurring complaint | Import-oriented | 250+ platforms, 70+ auto-synctheir claim |
| Analytics depth | Day/time, tags, symbols, options, cohorts | Strong trade analytics and journaling UX | Behavioural and process | Deepest — 600+ stats, custom dashboards |
| Psychology tooling | Discipline report, rule follow-rate | Journaling and tags, not Edgewonk depth | Deepest — Tiltmeter class | Behaviour patterns, not specialist |
| AI on your trades | AI Chat on every plan, free included | Zella AI, heavily marketed | Not the positioning | AI Coach and summaries, paid tiers |
| Prop-firm focus | Journals eval accounts | Strongest — mindshare and workflow | Not the positioning | Eval journaling, not a rule engine |
Read the full comparison
TradeReview vs TradeZella
The price gap is the story: roughly $35/mo with no free tier against free-to-start and $9.90. Where TradeZella still wins: prop-firm workflows and community.
Compare →TradeReview vs Edgewonk
Psychology depth against mobile and price. Edgewonk’s behavioural tooling is deeper; we are cheaper, free to start, and on your phone.
Compare →TradeReview vs TradesViz
Two journals with real free tiers and native apps on both sides. TradesViz goes far deeper on statistics; we are simpler to live in day to day.
Compare →How we compare them
Four rules, so you can judge how much weight to give a page written by one of the vendors in it.
- 01
Public sources only. Prices and feature claims come from each vendor’s own site, linked on every page.
- 02
Dated, not evergreen. Every page carries the date it was last verified. Pricing moves; undated comparisons are worthless.
- 03
We name where we lose. Psychology to Edgewonk, statistics depth to TradesViz, prop-firm workflows to TradeZella.
- 04
Affiliate position, stated. TradeReview runs its own affiliate program; these pages carry no paid placements for competitors.
Comparison questions
What is the best trading journal in 2026?
It depends on what you are solving. For starting free across several markets with mobile review, TradeReview. For psychology, Edgewonk. For statistics depth, TradesViz. For prop-firm evaluations, TradeZella. Our choosing guide works through the trade-offs.
Which trading journals have a real free plan?
TradeReview and TradesViz both do. TradeZella has no free tier, and Edgewonk offers a 14-day money-back guarantee rather than a free plan.
Can I trust a comparison written by one of the products?
Partly, and only if it is checkable. Every figure here links to the vendor’s own page and carries a verification date, and we state the three categories where a competitor beats us. Read the rival’s site too.
How often are these pages updated?
Each page is re-verified against the vendors’ pricing pages and stamped with the date. This set was last checked on 15 September 2026.
The cheapest way to compare is to try one.
TradeReview’s free plan needs no card, so the trial costs you nothing but an evening.